MAGA Is No Longer America First

And the Republican Party is suffering for it. The fractures are deep.

Sponsored by

Your Retirement Savings Need to Outlast You

Most retirement plans underestimate two things: how long your savings need to last, and how quietly inflation erodes them along the way.

The 15-Minutes Retirement Plan helps you close both gaps with practical guidance on longevity risk, purchasing power, and building a financial plan that doesn't run out before you do.

If you have $1,000,000 or more saved, download your free guide to start.

It pains to say, but MAGA can no longer be considered America First. (Let us know what you think in the poll at the bottom)

The movement that once promised to end endless wars, slash wasteful spending, and put American workers, families, and infrastructure ahead of foreign entanglements has lost its way. What began as a populist revolt against globalist elites and neoconservative nation-building has quietly transformed into a vehicle for the same old interventionist policies that conservatives once decried. The prime example stares us in the face today: the escalating war with Iran. American tax dollars—billions upon billions—are being funneled into airstrikes, naval deployments, and military operations halfway around the world. And for what? Ordinary citizens see no reduction in their grocery bills, no relief on their mortgages, no stronger borders, and no safer streets. Just like the decade-long disasters in Iraq and Afghanistan, this conflict delivers zero measurable benefits to the people who foot the bill.

Consider the cold fiscal reality. For years, fiscal conservatives warned that pouring trillions into Middle Eastern conflicts was bankrupting the nation while enriching defense contractors and foreign interests. Rep. Thomas Massie put it bluntly: “We’ve spent $8 trillion in the Middle East. That’s 100 X annual federal spending on roads and bridges. Picture how great our country could be if we’d spent that $ here. Imagine how affordable groceries & housing would be if we hadn’t printed all that $.” His words ring truer than ever as the Iran War adds fresh layers to that mountain of debt. Every missile launched, every troop deployment, and every supply chain stretched across oceans represents money yanked from American pockets. That cash could have repaired crumbling bridges in the heartland, funded tax cuts for working families, or bolstered domestic manufacturing to bring jobs back from China. Instead, it fuels inflation that squeezes homeowners and empties supermarket shelves. The printing presses at the Federal Reserve churn out more dollars to cover the tab, devaluing the savings of retirees and young families alike. This is not America First.

The pattern is painfully familiar. Conservatives who supported the initial push into Afghanistan and Iraq after 9/11 eventually woke up to the truth: these wars cost over $8 trillion when you tally direct spending, veteran care, and interest on borrowed money. They delivered no lasting stability, no reliable allies, and certainly no economic windfall for the United States. American soldiers came home scarred or in coffins, while the homeland struggled with opioid epidemics, rust-belt decay, and unchecked illegal immigration. MAGA rose precisely to reject that failed approach. It vowed to negotiate peace deals, avoid new conflicts, and redirect resources inward. Yet here we are, repeating the script with Iran. The justifications sound eerily similar—threats to allies, regional stability, preventing worse outcomes. But the results will be the same: higher national debt, more inflation passed onto consumers, and distracted leadership that cannot focus on fixing the southern border or rebuilding supply chains.

This abandonment of America First principles runs deeper than one conflict. From a conservative viewpoint, the shift shows up in multiple policy failures that prioritize foreign commitments over domestic renewal. Take foreign aid, for instance. Traditional conservatives have long argued that sending hundreds of billions overseas—whether to prop up distant governments or fund international organizations—starves vital domestic needs. Under the current MAGA-aligned leadership, aid packages continue flowing even as U.S. veterans sleep on sidewalks and infrastructure crumbles. Why pour resources into stabilizing far-flung regions when American cities face skyrocketing crime and failing schools? True America First would demand a full audit of every dollar sent abroad and a ruthless redirection toward rebuilding our own military bases, ports, and highways. Instead, the focus remains outward, leaving working-class taxpayers to shoulder the burden through higher prices and stagnant wages.

Another glaring example is the neglect of energy independence in favor of global alliances. Conservatives cheered when America achieved energy dominance through domestic drilling and pipelines. It lowered gas prices, strengthened national security, and reduced reliance on hostile foreign powers. Yet in the rush toward Iran escalation, that hard-won independence is sidelined. Sanctions, naval blockades, and supply disruptions threaten to spike fuel costs again, hitting truckers, farmers, and families hardest. An America First agenda would double down on drilling here at home, exporting our surplus to friendly nations on our terms, and using that leverage to avoid costly military adventures. The current path does the opposite: it risks energy shocks that enrich foreign oil producers while American consumers pay the price at the pump.

Real America First conservatives also point to the ballooning defense budget without corresponding accountability. Massive increases in military spending sound patriotic on paper, but when they fund open-ended commitments abroad without clear victory conditions, they become just another form of big-government waste. The same voices that once demanded balanced budgets and entitlement reform now seem content to let the national debt soar past $36 trillion. Imagine if even a fraction of the Iran War allocation went toward tax relief for small businesses or vocational training programs that actually prepare American workers for high-paying jobs. The result would be stronger families, more innovation at home, and genuine economic growth. Instead, the money vanishes into foreign sands, leaving future generations with interest payments that crowd out every other priority.

Border security offers yet another conservative indictment of this drift. While there have been some wins on this issue under Trump, America First was supposed to mean sealing the southern border, ending catch-and-release policies, and prioritizing American citizens over illegal entrants. Yet foreign policy obsessions consume the oxygen in Washington. Resources and political capital that could finish the wall, hire more agents, or reform asylum rules get diverted to overseas crises. Millions of illegal crossings continue, straining welfare systems, depressing wages in blue-collar sectors, and importing crime and fentanyl that kills tens of thousands yearly. Conservatives who built their careers on immigration enforcement watch in dismay as the movement they supported trades real domestic enforcement for symbolic gestures abroad. This is not putting citizens first; it is classic elite distraction tactics.

The cultural and economic fallout compounds the betrayal. Inflation from war spending hits the poorest Americans hardest—seniors on fixed incomes, single parents, and factory workers. Housing prices remain out of reach because the trillions printed for past and present conflicts devalued the dollar. Groceries cost more, fuel eats into paychecks, and the American Dream slips further away. Meanwhile, defense contractors and foreign lobbies thrive. This was never the conservative vision. Ronald Reagan talked of peace through strength, not perpetual conflict. Pat Buchanan warned against the dangers of empire. Even in recent decades, voices within the right called for restraint, arguing that true patriotism means securing the republic at home rather than policing the globe.

The Iran War crystallizes how far the movement has strayed. No credible threat justifies indefinite involvement when our own backyard demands attention. Americans are not safer because of it; they are poorer, more divided, and less optimistic about the future. The promise of America First was simple: end the waste, rebuild the heartland, and make government work for the people who built this country. That promise lies broken. Fiscal conservatives, libertarians within the right, and everyday patriots who voted for change deserve better. They deserve leaders who recognize that every dollar spent in Tehran or the Strait of Hormuz is a dollar not spent on American roads, schools, or security.

Reclaiming America First will require hard choices—ending open-ended foreign wars, slashing non-essential overseas spending, and redirecting every resource toward domestic renewal. Until that happens, the label rings hollow. It pains to admit the drift, but honesty demands it. The movement that once inspired millions with its focus on the forgotten man must rediscover its roots, or risk becoming indistinguishable from the globalist establishment it replaced. The American people, bearing the costs in blood and treasure, are watching. They deserve a government that finally puts them first.

Do you think MAGA is still American First?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.